16. A LETTER TO WELLS FARGO BANK [June, ’18]
This was written in June of 2018
I don’t know if I’m just getting grumpy in my old age, or if I just am tired of all the lies that I soak and marinate in every day via all the media. Oh, you know:
I’m your friend; I’m here to help you. You just have to . . .
buy me;
eat me;
drink me;
smoke me;
admire me;
be happy with me;
have faith in me;
be beautiful with/for me;
fuck me;
own me;
trust me;
use me;
wear me;
be loyal to me;
send me a check;
have a nicer car;
vote for me;
keep up with me;
be more with it;
etc. etc. etc.
etc. etc.
etc.
etc.
etc.
etc.
etc.
etc.
Anyway, I went to my bank two weeks ago, to make a bank wire transfer. As it happened, I was directed to a newbie bank officer with whom to do the necessary paperwork. Being a newbie, he was accompanied by a (female) supervisor who helped him through the various steps. I’d never met either of them before, and between the three of us we did this task in about 20 minutes. The next day I got a follow-up email telling me the status of the wire transfer. The email said:
“Good Afternoon Ervin,
I just wanted to follow up with you in regards to the wire we processed yesterday at the banking center. As we discussed it will be going out Monday due to it being late in the afternoon. And I wanted also to thank you for your continued business with us. Your relationship is important to me and I appreciated having the opportunity to assist you. My goal is to help you succeed financially and to provide you with an exceptional level of service, while ensuring your service requests are met.
If you have questions, or would like assistance or information please call me using the information below.
Thank you. We appreciate your business.
(The guy’s name appeared here, without a “yours”, “sincerely”, or other sign-off word or phrase)
I sent him the following response:
Hi, Mr. ________;
Thank you for getting back to me, and I appreciate your help in the matter of the international wire transfer.
You emailed me the standard politenesses about appreciating my business and eagerness to assist me. It’s nice of you to say things like that; but if you’ll forgive me, that is not my experience of Wells Fargo bank. I’ll tell you up front that this is not your fault; it’s just that banking at Wells Fargo is unpleasant for me.
Over the years I have seen Wells Far-to-go turn from a reasonably friendly bank full of people whom I’d see every time I went there into a building that is perpetually full of strangers. I’ve seen tellers, officials, loan officers, managers, personal bankers, credit card staffers, portfolio advisors, etc. come and go countless times. The parking lot attendants have longer tenure. There’s only one person left that I recognize from long ago: ______; and she’ll be retiring soon. _____ has been around for a while, and so has that very nice ______ (?) fellow whom I sometimes bring a coffee for. But everyone else is a stranger to me.
I met you and Ms. _____ for the first time only last week, over the matter of the bank wire transfer. You greeted me when I walked through the door. In the past three months I’ve been greeted at the door by three other people whom I’d never seen before and have not seen again. As things are going, both you and Ms. _____ will both soon leave and I’ll never see either of you again. The very nice connection I made with her will disappear forever. Wells Fargo is not really there to help me, I’m afraid. If it were, there would be familiar faces for me to feel comfortable with, and to have built up some familiarity with and create some sense of community. Frankly, I have a more personal relationship with my grocery store checkout person, whom I at least see most times I go there. But this is not your fault.
A bit of history: I’ve banked at that branch of Wells Fargo since before you were born. As I said, you and met for the first time only last week. I am twice your age and I come from a different generation and culture than you do. It would be polite for someone in your position to address me as Mr. Somogyi. You have, as far as I’m concerned, no license to do differently.
It’s a bit awkward to point this out but, while it is common in this culture to casually call people by their first names, ours is a professional/commercial relationship in which we are not friends or equals. You don’t know me; I don’t know you; and you are paid to deal with me. As a matter of fact, Wells Fargo makes the money with which it pays you directly off my patronage, and that of others like me. I’m fairly responsible about things like how people address one another; I was brought up to call my elders Mr. or Mrs., or even Ms. You may not have noticed that I am at least three times your age.
Please forgive me for this longish letter; you’ve done almost nothing to deserve it. You are not responsible for the bulk of my frustrations. I’m sure you have your own troubles. But you should have some idea about manners.
Years ago my bank branch was full of visible and audible activity. Now, when I walk in it’s almost deserted. There are two (or occasionally three) tellers at ten teller’s windows. The other seven or eight windows look like cemeteries waiting for a visitor. That’s probably because everyone is doing electronic banking. But I’m old-fashioned and I go to the bank. And these days that feels sort of like sitting next to the girl no one wants to dance with; the effect on me is somewhere between disconcerting and creepy.
Mostly, however, it’s not that the bank is inefficient or thoughtless or greedy; your employer is a criminal. You work for a criminal organization. Wells Far-to-go claims to be benevolent and civically responsible, but it famously opened MILLIONS of unauthorized accounts for its customers without their knowing about it. It didn’t really have to do that, you know; but it did because it could. It refunded the money, of course (or claimed it did); but it did so unwillingly and under threat once the secret was out.
My honest opinion is that Wells Fargo’s board of vastly overpaid directors should rot in a Nicaraguan prison. A few people did lose their jobs over that act of out-and-out piracy, but not much more than that happened. Wells Far-to-go participated in the financial debacle of circa 2008; it also has financed and continues to finance all kinds of corporate projects that devastate the environment and is PRIMARILY focused on making money for its already moneyed customers. Its mortgage track record ranges from unsatisfactory to horrible; I know that from experience and from others who have spoken with me. I also have a friend who is a financial attorney, who has spoken with me about having had way too much experience with how utterly shabby, shady, and corrupt Wells Far-to-go’s behaviors and policies on the whole have been.
I’m embarrassed to be one of Wells Fargo’s customers. Not that most of the other big banks are any different. But I don’t know of any more benign bank to put my money into.
You are a youngish man trying to make his way through life and who has found a career with this institution. And you are simply doing your job. I mean you no ill or disrespect whatsoever. As far as I know, you are not dishonest and you are not in a position to engage in malfeasance. You should, though, observe the niceties of acknowledging your elders with some politeness; and in your job most of the elders you meet are not your friends; you’re engaging in monetary transactions. I’ve met people at that bank over the years that I’ve honestly liked. However, I’m unable to like Wells Fargo itself.
Once, a long time ago, the bank had mounted a promotional campaign that advertised business loans to small and struggling community businesses. Being young, and starting a struggling small business, I applied for such a loan. The bank official I spoke with seemed to be kindly disposed toward the young and naive young person I was at the time, and told me straight out that despite what they say in their advertising the bank has little to no interest in that kind of activity, and wouldn’t loan me anything. Those weren’t his precise words but that was EXACTLY what he said to me. Ditto with my mortgage some years later: Wells Far-to-go said yes almost right off the bat, of course; and then it said no. In the world of sales, this is called bait-and-switch.
Today, a bank wire transfer should go through to any place in the world in microseconds. I’d give the paperwork, etc., 24 hours, max. As it is, I was told that it may take five to ten business days . . . during which, in addition to the fee that I was charged, Wells Fargo gets to use my money gratis for that length of time. As far as service goes, whom exactly is that a service to? Well, it is business as usual, is it not?
I may or may not see you next time I go to the bank. If I do, I’ll offer to bring you a cup of coffee. Ditto Ms. ________. Nothing of what I’ve been writing is your or her fault . . . although, as I intimated above, I’ve been subject to the bank’s various business practices for as long as you’ve been on this planet (and I think Ms. ________’s lifetime too). Finally, Wells Fargo has made money off me every month and every year of that time. Coffee-wise, I usually go to the place up the block; they have decent coffee.
Respectfully (toward you, not the bank), Ervin Somogyi